The Comparison of CCP and Soviet Propagandas — Agriculture and Industry(7)

Himalaya Canada Toronto Maple Leaf Farm     Owl

One of the most important features of communism is the system of public ownership. To achieve the goal of public ownership, both countries implemented major political changes that involved collectivization and the concentration of industrial production.

Stalin used a planned economy. He created a series of Five Year Plans. In the first Five Year Plan, Stalin wanted convert the Soviet Union from an agrarian culture to an industrial country without being indebted to other foreign countries. . In order to control wealth and maintain high agriculture output for export (to generate income to buy the necessary materials and knowledge), Stalin forced farmers to contribute all their food, farm implements, and animals to the state. The famers were then forced to work collectively. The majority of their harvests were taken by the government. This activity resulted famine, which lead huge number of deaths (estimates from 6 to 10 million). However, all of that death was ignored; the government was only focused on changing the economy. The collectivization of farms helped to establish the industrialization of the Soviet Union (McKinney, pres. 2).

The same style of collectivization and industrialization from 1958-1961 in communist China was called the Great Leap Forward. The goal of Great Leap Forward was same as that of the Five-year Plan of the Soviet Union. However, in China agricultural output was actually dramatically decreased due to the collectivization. As in the Soviet Union, the negative side effects were totally ignored (estimated 18 to 45 million deaths due to famine). The propaganda of the time presented people who were happy to contribute their food, and happy in their collectivization and hard working for industrialization. The propaganda of China is quite similar to the propaganda of the Soviet Union for the similar period .

Struggle for a good harvest and store food supplies everywhere (Linshing and Tompkins 57).

Contributes food for the country, 1950
(Ехориа and иоффе  93)
Collection is the way to the rich communism, 1958-1961
5 year plan, 4 year finish! 1948 (Ехориа and иоффе  49);
The poster presents a worker works hard for produce steel.
Produce more coal for the country, 1949 (Ехориа and иоффе 51)
“Make every effort to develop the coal industy,”1976 (right) (Wolf 201).

Although the Great Leap Forward was learned from Soviet, there are major differences between the two countries. In a type of boasting, the Chinese people started to lie about the output. For example, farmers were reporting that each 667 square meters of farm was producing 5,000 to 10,000 kilograms of wheat. These exaggerated claims were referred to as a launch satellite, in deference to the launch Sputnik 1 and Sputnik 2 by the Soviets in 1957. That is, the Chinese people used the analogy of launching a satellite to represent the great step forward in their agricultural; output. Of course, it was all a lie. The normal output from such a field is – at most — about 250 kilograms (Yang 299). 

The propaganda based on the analogy of launching a satellite to represent increased agricultural output.

In the Great Leap Forward, Mao issued the decree that steel output had to exceed that of America and Britain.  All people had join in the production of steel. Small “backyard” collectives were forced to smelt iron ore. Unfortunately, the technology was very limited and, most of the output was totally useless. However, this useless output was ignored – it was still included in the official totals of steel production.

Communist China also built many water managements projects (e.g., dams such as the Banquia and Shimantan dams on the Huai River, to control water, irrigation, and provide power) during Great Leap Forward. These were a source of national pride (see Figure 28, but they were often badly designed and built, and as such, have created numerous problems that are often worse than those that they were intended to solve (the failure of the Banqiao dam complex cost 85,000 lives). Most have since failed or been rebuilt (Yang 134).

Do not depend on nature (Cushing and Tompkins 43).

  Summary

It is always important and interesting to learn history from a visually perspective. From analysis the propagandas it is very obviously that Soviet was a model of Chinese communist. The visual arts provide more directly details than reading written history. From learn the communist visual arts, one can directly see how much communist China have imitated from Soviet and miserable the consequence the both countries had.

Reference

“A collection of culture revolution propagandas”. Mimifr . Aug, 19, 2007. Web April 10,     2013.

Bakke, Lars Hasvoll. “Propaganda Design & Aesthetics: Soviet Retro Posters”.

         CRESTOCK. 24 April, 2008. Web. April 1, 2013.

Branderberger, David. Propaganda State in Crisis. New Haven and London: Yale

            University press. 2011. Print.

Chen, Peihua. Mao Zedong and Red Guard. Seattle: Univer of Washinghton; London:

         Macmillan Press. 2011. Print.

China – A Century of Revolution: China in Revolution (1911-1949). Winstar, 1997.

            Documentary.

“Chinese propaganda posters”. Jazjaz. Oct 12, 2007.Web. March 5, 2013

Cushing, Lincoln and Tompkin, Ann. Chinese Posters Art from the Great Proletarian

         Cultural Revolution. San Farncisco. 2007. Print.

“Foreign Friends: Soviet Union.” Chinese Posters. Jan 2, 2013. April 20, 2013.

“Joseph Stalin (1879 – 1953)”.BBC.co.uk. British Broadcast Corp, 2013. Web.

“Korea War”. Xinhua Net. Web. 22 April, 2013

Lafont, Maria. Soviet Posters. The Sergo Grigorian collection. 2009. Prestel. Print.

Landsberger, Stefan.  Chinese Posters. The Iish- Landsberger Collections. Prestel. 2009

         Print.

“Lenin’s party was perished.”IfNews. Jan 15, 2008 Web. April 13, 2013.

McKinney, Stephanie L.“Joseph Stalin”.  About. Web. April 10, 2013

 “ Oct 3, 1949: Soviet Union establish diplomatic relations with China”. Cpc Pelple. Oct 3, 2010. Web. April 10, 2013.

“Photos of Young Mao Zedong”.BBS. Jan 13, 2013. Web. April 1, 2013.

“Pocta and Mayakovski.” Sina. Jun14, 2007. Web. April 16, 2013.

“Poster”. Soviet propaganda poster. 2013. Web. April 16, 2013.

Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-Tuno. Peking: Foreign Language Press. 1966. Print. “Serve the People.” Marxists. 2004 Web. Web. April 16, 2013.

“Stalin philosophy, the history of Bolshevist”. Ylgc. 2001. Web. April 13, 2013.

“Sun Yat-sen.” Encyclopeida Britannica. 2011 Web. April 10, 2013.

Suny, Ronald Grigor. “Beyond Psychology: the Yong Stalin in Gergia”. Jstor. Vol 50  No. 1. 1991: (48-58). Print.    

“Soviet WWII Propagandas.” Sohu. May 4, 2008. Web. April 16, 2013.

“The Soviet Army”. History Learning Site.  Web. April 10, 2013

 “Vibrant Chinese Propaganda Art – Part 1: Revolution, Revolution, Revolution”.

CRESTOCK. 6 May 2009.Web. April 16, 2013

Wolf, Michael. Chinese Propaganda Posters. Taschen. 2003. Print.   

Yang, Jisheng. Tombstone: Chinese Fame Record, 1958-1962. Hong Kong: Tiandi press. 2010. Print.

Довлядкая, Ехориа and иоффе, марк. Soviet Union Propagandas. Beijing: People Art press. 1954. Print.

УСТРАШАЯ ДА НЕ УСТРАШИСЬ. Основоположник советского плаката сбежал от красных в 1919 г.Livejournal. Jan 25, 2013. Web. April 1, 2013.

Links:

How CCP’s propaganda had developed from Soviet Union(1)-Gnews

A Brief History of Soviet Propaganda (2)Gnews

A Brief History of Chinese Propoganda (3)-Gnews

The Comparison of CCP and Soviet Propagandas (4)-Gnews

The Comparison of CCP and Soviet Propagandas– Great Leaders(5)-Gnews

The Comparison of CCP and Soviet Propagandas–Military(6)-Gnews

+4
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments